Safety & Our FutureIssue #28

Nuclear Weapons — Fewer, Safer, On a Path to Zero

The Doomsday Clock sits at 85 seconds to midnight — the closest in 79 years. No single person should hold unchecked authority over the most consequential decision in human history.

85s
to midnight on the Doomsday Clock — the closest in 79 years of nuclear history
12,241
nuclear warheads worldwide
~2,100 on hair-trigger alert · 89% held by US (~5,177) and Russia (~5,459)
$120–149B
saved over 30 years from Sentinel cancellation alone
Full triad → submarine-bomber dyad saves hundreds of billions more without reducing deterrence
Section 01
Overview

The two-minute version.

The President holds sole unchecked authority to launch. New START expired February 2026 with no successor. 12,241 warheads worldwide. A new arms race has begun.

Fewer warheads. No First Use by statute. Deterrence through submarines, not destabilizing ICBMs. Restore arms control. Verified path to minimum deterrent.

$50B+ per year redirected. Launch-on-warning eliminated. Iran diplomacy restored. Treaty architecture rebuilt. The Doomsday Clock starts moving back.

You just read the simple version. Keep scrolling for the full picture.Next: What's broken
Section 02
What's Broken

The United States has never adopted a No First Use policy. The President holds sole, unchecked, legally unregulated authority to launch the entire arsenal. Under launch-on-warning posture, the decision window is approximately 10 minutes — based on sensor data that has produced false alarms. 61% of Americans are uncomfortable with this arrangement. The 1983 Petrov incident and 1995 Yeltsin activation were near-misses survived only by individual human judgment.

Source: [PAPER] §The Problem (NTI)

For the first time since 1972, no treaty limits either US or Russian arsenals. New START expired February 5, 2026 with no successor. Both sides are now legally free to increase their arsenals without limit. China has built approximately 350 new ICBM silos and DOD projects 1,000+ operational Chinese warheads by 2030. The conditions for a three-way arms race are now in place.

Source: [PAPER] §The Problem (Arms Control Association + DOD)

The Pentagon is spending $946 billion over 2025–2034 on full nuclear triad modernization — $95 billion per year, more than the entire federal contribution to K-12 education. The Sentinel ICBM breached the Nunn-McCurdy Act with an 81% cost overrun, from $78 billion to $140.9 billion. The Pentagon issued a 'no alternatives' finding to waive the breach rather than cancel the program — despite cancellation being endorsed by Secretaries Perry and Mattis, General Cartwright, and 716 scientists including 10 Nobel laureates.

Source: [PAPER] §The Problem (CBO + Arms Control Association)

The JCPOA extended Iran's nuclear breakout timeline to 12 months with the most comprehensive verification regime ever applied. Its abandonment compressed that timeline to under 2 weeks. North Korea has ~50 assembled warheads, fissile material for ~90 more, and is adding ~6 per year. Treaty architecture — the mechanism that actually kept both superpowers below catastrophe for 60 years — has been abandoned.

Source: [PAPER] §The Problem

How the US compares.

What Americans face vs. what peer nations achieve.

MeasureUSPeer Nation
Treaties limiting US/Russian arsenals01 (New START until Feb 2026)(First time since 1972)
No First Use policyNoSince 1964(🇨🇳 China · 60+ years)
Sentinel ICBM cost overrun+81%Baseline($78B → $140.9B)
Iran breakout timeline< 2 weeks12 months(Under JCPOA (2015))
Section 03
Our Plan

"This is not weakness. China has maintained No First Use since 1964 without sacrificing deterrence credibility. NFU reduces crisis instability — it lowers adversary pressure to launch on warning, reduces the temperature in escalation scenarios, and strengthens the normative framework that deterrence depends on."

The Common Good Party — Nuclear Weapons Policy

What the CGP plan actually does

Adopt No First Use by statute
Not executive order — reversible only by Congress. Any nuclear first use without Congressional declaration of war triggers mandatory post-use accountability proceedings.
Reform presidential launch authority
Require consensus of President + Vice President + Secretary of Defense for any nuclear first use order. The Markey-Lieu Act codified as permanent statute.
Eliminate launch-on-warning posture
Shift to 'ride-out' posture using submarines. A single Ohio-class submarine can destroy any nation; the deterrent survives any first strike.
Cancel the Sentinel ICBM
81% cost overrun. Endorsed for cancellation by Secretaries Perry and Mattis, General Cartwright, and 716 scientists including 10 Nobel laureates. Move to a submarine-bomber dyad.
Reduce to 1,000 deployed strategic warheads
Verified successor to New START. SIPRI confirms 1,000+ warheads are more than sufficient for deterrence. Long-term goal: ~300 for minimum deterrent.
Ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty
In force as monitoring regime since 1996 — detected all six North Korean tests. US ratification provides decisive push for universalization.
Restore Iran diplomacy (JCPOA+)
Return to the 2015 framework with longer sunset, broader missile coverage, updated verification. Alternative: nuclear-armed Iran within this decade.
North Korea interim freeze framework
Verified freeze on testing and fissile production. Caps on delivery systems. Humanitarian engagement. Not a path to normalization — a path to containment.
Section 04
How Your Life Changes

On Day 1, the 10-minute decision window disappears. Launch-on-warning posture — dependent on sensor data that has produced false alarms repeatedly — is eliminated through a shift to ride-out posture using submarines. No First Use becomes law, not presidential discretion. Presidential launch authority requires consensus of three senior officials, introducing deliberation into the most consequential decision in human history. The Doomsday Clock, at 85 seconds to midnight, begins measurable movement away from catastrophe.

In Years 2–5, the Sentinel ICBM is cancelled. Minuteman III retires at end of service life. Plutonium pit production at Savannah River — bogged in litigation, 10+ years from operational, projected $25B+ — is defunded entirely. New START successor negotiations begin immediately; a verified reduction framework is established. Iran JCPOA+ returns with updated verification, compressing breakout timeline back from 2 weeks toward 12 months. North Korea freeze framework operational with caps on fissile production and testing.

In Years 3–10, Hanford (Washington) cleanup accelerates — projected $364–589B through 2100+ with 65 square miles of contaminated groundwater now on a permanent DOE obligation. Runit Dome remediation in the Marshall Islands begins before rising seas wash nuclear waste into the Pacific. 500+ abandoned uranium mines on Navajo land are cleaned up as an environmental justice obligation. RECA is permanently reauthorized — Indigenous, Pacific Islander, and downwinder communities no longer re-litigate their right to compensation every few years.

Over the decade, $50 billion per year in redirected savings flows to healthcare, climate, education, and environmental cleanup. 2,056 nuclear tests killed an estimated 4 million people prematurely; those communities receive permanent acknowledgment and support. The arsenal continues shrinking toward a minimum deterrent of ~300 warheads. And the most dangerous instrument of the Cold War is finally being placed under the accountability framework a democracy demands.

What changes on day one

No First Use becomes law
Removes unchecked presidential first-strike authority. Any change requires Congress.
Presidential launch authority is shared
President + VP + SecDef consensus required for any nuclear first use.
Launch-on-warning posture eliminated
Ride-out capability using submarines replaces the 10-minute decision window.
ICBMs de-alerted from hair-trigger
Removes immediate launch risk from false alarms while maintaining the deterrent.
Congressional Gang of Eight notified
Any nuclear decision consideration triggers legislative awareness before presidential action.
CTBT submitted to Senate for ratification
Global testing norm strengthened. US ratification unlocks universalization.
IAEA safeguards funding increased
Verification capacity strengthened across all arms control agreements.

"The JCPOA extended Iran's breakout timeline to 12 months with the most comprehensive verification regime ever applied. Its abandonment compressed that timeline to under 2 weeks. Every arms control skeptic must account for this empirical record before arguing that diplomacy is naive."

CGP Nuclear Weapons Paper — §Our Policy
Section 05
What Works Globally
🇨🇳
China
No First Use since 1964 — 60+ years while modernizing
~500warheads · proof NFU is compatible with deterrence
🇿🇦
South Africa
Voluntary disarmament — dismantled 6 weapons under IAEA inspection (1989)
Onlynation to independently develop then verifiably dismantle an arsenal
🇬🇧
United Kingdom
Extended deterrence + AUKUS — conditional arsenal, NFU-compatible
Minimumdeterrent · NATO ally demonstrating security without first-use ambiguity
🇷🇺
Russia
New START treaty partner (expired Feb 2026) · must be successor target
~5,459warheads · 1,558 tactical (vs. US ~150) · successor treaty must cover tactical
Section 06
Compare Parties

See where every side actually stands.

Current federal law, the Democratic Party's 2024 platform, the Republican Party's 2024 platform, and our plan — side by side, sourced to the record.

Open the side-by-side comparison
Section 07
Full Policy Paper
The complete legislative framework

The homework other parties skip. We did it.

Sourced, cited, costed, and written to a standard that could walk into a legislative office tomorrow. 5,229 words across 10 pillars.

Sources & references
See also